5 Most Toxic Ingredients in Eyeliner

5 Most Toxic Ingredients in Eyeliner

Is your eyeliner toxic? 


Avoid these 5 ingredients to prevent eye irritation.


We've heard it all before..

"Don't use these products."

"This causes cancer!"

But seriously, there are a few ingredients that can cause major irritation and even more severe long term effects to your health. We're going to break down the 5 most common ingredients found in eyeliner, what they're used for, what names they are typically disguised as, and why to avoid them.


1. Carbon Black


carbon black ingredient cosmetics eyeliner

Long story short, carbon black is made from petroleum oil. It is most commonly found in eyeliner, eyeshadow and mascara to give it a deep black pigment. It's a cheap alternative to other black colorings so it's often found in inexpensive products.


Common names are: D&C Black No. 2, acetylene black, channel black, and thermal black.

Why you should avoid it:

While the health effects are still actively being tested, there have been some notable discoveries thus far. And remember, cigarettes were considered healthy for decades! So just because testing isn't complete, doesn't mean an ingredient is ok.

Health effect information:

Canada - Expected to be toxic or harmful.

Europe - May be toxic to reproduction when inhaled.

USA - Color use NOT APPROVED for cosmetic use around eye.


2. Parabens


paraben ingredient cosmetics


What is a paraben? It's a type of preservative mostly used in skincare and hair products, but still can be found in several cosmetics. This ingredient allows products to have an extended shelf life and prevents the growth of mold and bacteria.


Common names are: Ethylparaben, butylparaben, methylparaben, propylparaben, isobutylparaben, isopropylparaben, and any ingredient ending in "paraben."


Why you should avoid it:

Parabens are an endocrine disrupter, which means it messes with your body's hormones. In women, it mimics the hormone "oestrogen," which can increase breast cell division and accelerate the development of breast cancer.

Health effect information:

 Europe - A substance of very high concern due to endocrine disrupting properties

- Strong evidence of human endocrine disruption

Cosmetic Ingredient Review Assessments - Strong evidence of human skin allergan.



3. Lead


lead ingredient cosmetics eyeliner


Lead.. in cosmetics?! You bet. While it is not legal to have lead or lead byproducts I cosmetics, there is a legal threshold of acceptable amounts (10ppm). Product recalls are common for containing lead levels that exceed the threshold. Since lead is a naturally occurring element, it is common for trace amounts to appear in other color pigments.


Common names: Lead isn't allowed in products as a listed ingredient, therefore it is best to stay updated on product recalls for safe threshold violations.

Why you should avoid it:

Can cause cancer, reproductive and organ toxicity.

Most countries have banned it's use in cosmetics, however the US allows restricted amounts.


4. BAK (Benzalkonium chloride)


Benzalkonium chloride cosmetic ingredient eyeliner


Benzalkonium chloride is a preservative found in mascara and eyeliner to prevent the growth of bacteria and mold.

Common names: Zephiran, alkyldimethylbenzylammonium chloride

Why you should avoid it:

Human skin allergen - strong evidence.

Human immune toxicant or allergen - strong evidence.


5. Prime yellow carnauba wax


Prime yellow carnauba wax cosmetic ingredient harm


Carnauba wax is used to stiffen products and make them waterproof. Seems harmless right? I mean what can wax really do that's that bad? Read on to find out how it's harmful.

Common names: Copernicia cerifera wax, Palm wax.

Why you should avoid it:

While carnauba wax is not toxic, the wax can clog pores in the eye area and lead to dry eye disease, styes and other infections.



 Final thoughts

It can be challenging to know what ingredients are safe in cosmetic products, but rest assured that with a little research and help you can stock up on clean cosmetics.

At Bali Lash, we provide non toxic, vegan products so you won't have to ever second guess what you're putting on your skin.

Check out our adhesive eyeliner if you're looking to update your eyeliner to a toxic free one.


shop now adhesive eyeliner


*For further information please check out



Read more

Magnetic Eyeliner vs. Adhesive Eyeliner

Magnetic Eyeliner vs. Adhesive Eyeliner

Single Use vs. Reusable Cotton Rounds

Single Use vs. Reusable Cotton Rounds

Best False Eyelash Glue Alternatives

Best False Eyelash Glue Alternatives


Be the first to comment.
All comments are moderated before being published.